EDR Case Law

Canada
Canada R. v. Daley, 2003 NBQB 20, S/CR/7/02 (2003)
Canada R. v. Gauthier, 2003 QCCQ, Case No. 500-01-013375-016 (2003)
Canada R. v. Gratton, 2003 ABQB 728, Case No. 016051344Q (2003)
Canada R. v. Brander, 2003 ABQB 756, Case No. 017156316Q1 (2003)
Canada R. v. Robinson, 2007 CanLII 5369 (ON S.C.), Case No. CR-06-00002513-00 (2007)
Canada R. v. Cote, 2007 SKPC 100 (2007)
Canada R. v. Dagenais, 2009 SKQB, Case No. 242259881 (2009)
Canada R. v. Moxam, 2009 ABPC 300, Docket No. 071317655P1 (2009)
Canada R. v. Gill, 2009 ONCJ 675 (2009)
Canada R. v. M.R.H., 2009 SKPC 83 (2009)
Canada R. v. Skeete, 2009 ONCJ 376, Docket No.
31119980713024 & 3111998 0713921 (2009)
Cooper v. Garrett, 2009 BCSC 35 (CanLII), Case No. M054973 (2009)
Burdett (Guardian Ad Litem v. Mohamed, 2010 BCSC 310, Docket No. M034055 (2010)
Canada R. v. Lanza, 2010 ABPC 78, Docket No. 081386112P1 (2010)
Canada R. v. Cianchino, 2010 ONCJ 298 (2010)
Canada R. v. Delorey, 2009 NSSC 421 (2009)
Canada R. v. Delorey Appeal, 2010 NSCA 65 (2010)
Canada R. v. Belec, 2009 QCCQ 632 (2009)
Hutton v. General Motors of Canada Limited, 2010 ABQB 606 (2010)
Canada R. v. Berner, 2010 BCPC 162 (2010)
Cooper v Garrett, 2009 BCSC 35 (2009)
Deering v. Scugog (Township), 2010 ONSC 5502 (2010)
Canada R. v. Combes, 2008 BCSC 1818 (2008)

United States
Lloyd v. General Motors Corporation, US Dist. Ct. South Carolina LEXIS 4164 (2006)
Cobb v. Dawson, US Dist. Ct. Georgia, LEXIS 4632 (2007)
U.S. v. Spencer, US Dist. Ct. New Mexico, Cr. No. 07-1 767 LH (2009)
Niemeyer v. Ford Motor Co., et al, US Dist. Ct. Nevada, 2:09-CV-2091 JCM (PAL) (2012)
The above link is to the court’s order on a number of motions, one of which relates to the admissibility of Event Data Recorder evidence.

Arizona
Arizona v. O’Brien, Superior Court of Arizona, Maricopa County, Case No. CR 2003-016197-001 DT (2004)

California
California v. Beeler, San Diego Superior Court, Case No. SCD158974 (2002)
California v. Sanchez, Ventura County Superior Court, Case No. 2001 9000 34 (2003)
California v. Garibay, San Diego Superior Court, Case No. DA MAL791 (2006)
California v. Whelan, San Fernando Superior Court, Case No. PA045773 (2006)
Ortner v. Enterprise Rent-a-Car and Ortiz, Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. YC048688 (2006)
Winstead v. Sanchez, Los Angeles Superior Court, San Bernardino County, Case No. SCVSS124902 (2006)
Yesenia Monroy v. City of Los Angeles, Los Angeles Police Department and Felipe Arreola, Los Angeles Superior Court, San Bernardino County, Case No. BC339263 (2006)
California v. Terrones, Riverside County Superior Court, Case No. SWF018754 (2007)
California v. Tafoya, Orange County Superior Court, Case No. 05ZF0121 (2008)
California v.
Sinclair, San Bernadino County, Rancho Cucamonga District Court, Case No. FV040333 (2008)
California v. Gandarilla, Orange County Superior Court, Case No. 08WF1592 (2009)
California v. Goodlake, San Diego Superior Court, Case No. CN268494 (2010)
California Appellate
California v. French, 3rd App. Dist. Ct., unpublished (2003)
California v. Knight, 5th App. Dist. Ct., unpublished (2004)
California v. Xinos, 6th App. Dist. Ct., Case No. H034305 (2011) - Depublished by Sup. Ct. (2011)
California v. Diaz, 4th App. Dist. Ct., Case No. E054299 (2013)

Colorado
Colorado v. Cain, 1st Judicial District Court, Jefferson County, Case No. 01 CR 967 (2002)
Colorado v. Hernandez, 18th Judicial District, Arapahoe County, Case No. 08 CR 2105 (2010)

Florida
Florida v. Walker, 20th Judicial Circuit, Lee County, Case No. 00-002866CF RTC (2003)
Florida v. Matos, 17th Judicial Circuit, Broward County, Case No. 02015762 CF 10A (2003)
Florida v. Ubals, 17th Judicial Circuit, Broward County, Case No. 01017144 CF 10A (2003)
Florida v. Derreza and Florida v. Grayson, 1st Judicial Circuit, Escambia County, Case No. 2004 CF 003842A/B (2005)
Lesser v. Collier County, 20th Judicial Circuit, Collier County, Case No. 04-CA-004905 (2005)
Previlus v. Gold, 11th Judicial Circuit, Miami-Dade County, Case No. 2002-6453-CA-01 (2006)
Florida v. Sabree, 17th Judicial Circuit, Broward County, Case No. 05010251 CF 10A (2006).
Florida v. McKinney, 4th Judicial Circuit, Duval County, Case No.16-2009-CF-000618-AXXX-MA (2009)
Keyes v. American International Insurance Companies, 14th Judicial Circuit, Jackson County, Case No. 08-7066CA (2009)

Florida Appellate
Matos v. Florida, Fourth District Court of Appeals, Case No. 4D03-2043 (2005)
Florida v. Abbey, Fourth District Court of Appeals, Case No. 4D09-88 (2010)
Peterson v. Florida, Second District Court of Appeals, Case No. 2D11-5083

Georgia
Anderson-Barahona v. General Motors Corp., Cobb County Circuit Court, Case No. 99A19714 (2000)

Hawaii
Hawaii v. Michael Baybado, Second Circuit Court, Case No. 04-1-0456(2) (2005)

Idaho
Idaho v. Cutting and Idaho v. Salois, First District Court, Kootenai County, Case No. CR-2006-23272 & CR-2006-23275 (2008)

Illinois
Illinois v. Carone, Kane County Circuit Court, Case No. 03-CF-515 (2005)

Illinois Appellate
Bachman, et al, v. General Motors Corp., Uftring Chevrolet-Oldsmobile, Delphi Automotive Systems and Delco Electronics Systems, Illinois App. Ct., 4th Dist., No. 4-01-0237, Appeal from Circuit Court of Woodford County, Case No. 98L21 (2002)
Illinois v. Barham, Illinois App. Ct, 5th Dist., No. 5-02-0047, Appeal from the Circuit Court of Johnson County, Case No. 00-CF-90 (2003)

Indiana
Indiana v. Tra Hibbard, Greene County Superior Court, Case No. 28D01 0910FC 500 (2010)

Indiana Appellate
Cansler v. General Motors Corporation, Indiana App. Ct, 2nd Dist., 765 NE 2d 698 (2002)

Kentucky
Kentucky v. Garner, Whitley County Circuit Court, Case No. 07-CR-111 (2008)

Louisiana
Batiste v. General Motors Corp and Allstate Insurance Co., Civil District Ct., Orleans Parish, Division I, Case No. 98-2613 (2000)
Vailes v. Caddo and Desoto Parish Police Commissions, 11th Judicial District Court, Desoto Parish, Case No. 66-452B (2007)
Louisiana v. Verret, 15th Judicial District Court, Lafayette Parish, Case No. 114269 (2008)
LaBorde, et al, v. Shelter Mutual Insurance, et al, 15th Judicial District Court, Lafayette Parish, Case No. C-2007-2066-K (2011). See Louisiana Appellate.

Louisiana Appellate
Batiste v. General Motors Corp and Allstate Insurance Co., Fourth Circuit, Case No. 2000-CA-2027 (2001)
LaBorde, et al, v. Shelter Mutual Insurance, et al, Third Circuit Court of Appeal, Case No. CW11-00956 (2011)
LaBorde, et al, v. Shelter Mutual Insurance, et al, Louisiana Supreme Court, Case No. 12-CC-0074 (2012)

Maine
Maine v. Howell, Somerset County Superior Court, Docket No. CR05427 (2006)

Massachusetts
Massachusetts v. Zimmerman, Peabody District Court, Case No. 0340-CR-0071 (2005)
Massachusetts v. Wilson, Hampden Superior Court, Case No. 04-1228 (2005)
Massachusetts v. Merry, Peabody District Court, Case No. 0786-CR-002004 (2008)

Massachusetts Appellate
Massachusetts v. Zimmerman, Case No. No. 06-P-1240 (2007).

Michigan
Michigan v. Wood, 56th Circuit Court, Case No. 02-283-FH (2003)
Michigan v. Schubert, 13th Circuit Court, Case No. 04-9625-FH (2005)
Michigan v. Farrell, 6th Circuit Court, Case No. 206-284-FH (2006)
Michigan v. Benson, 51st Circuit Court, Case No. 05-201565FH (2006)
Theodoroff v. Tucker and General Motors Corp., 3rd Circuit Court, Case No. 03-308716-NI (2007)
Michigan v. Druzynsk, 6th Circuit Court, Case No. CR-2007-212928-FH (2008)
Michigan v. Ball, 10th Circuit Court, Case No. 08-030433-FH (2009)

Minnesota
Minnesota v. Franco del Cid, 5th Judicial Circuit, Case No. 42-CR-08-220 (2008)
Minnesota v. Campbell, 2nd Judicial Circuit, Case No. 62-CR-09-7645 (2009)

Minnesota Appellate
Malith v. Soller, Court of Appeals, Case No. A09-2028 (2010)

Montana
Montana v. Winter, Flathead County District Court, Case No. DC-15-2009-0000424-IN (2011)

New Jersey Appellate
McAlonan v. Tracy, Toyota Motor Corp., and Toyota Sales, USA, Inc., Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division, Case No. A-6034-07T2 (2010)

New York
New York v. Christmann, Newark Village Court, Case No. 03110007 (2004)
New York v. Hopkins, Monroe County Court, Case No. 2004-0338 (2004)
People v. Slade, 233 N.Y.L.J. 11, Nassau County Superior Court (2005)
People v. Muscarnera, 1st District Court, Slip Op. 27224, 237 N.Y.L.J. 95 (2007)

Ohio
Ohio v. Larry Wilson, Perry County Common Pleas Court, Case No. 04-CR-0034
Ohio v. Jason Barron, Perry County Common Pleas Court, Case No. 04-CR-0035 (2005)

Ohio Appellate
Ohio v. Larry Wilson, 5th District Court of Appeals, Case No. 05CA5 (2005)
Howard v. Miami Township Fire Division, Ohio App. Ct. 1508 LEXIS 1394 (2007)

Oklahoma
Oklahoma v. Ingram, Cherokee County District Court, Case No. CF-2006-403 (2009)
Amend v. Unit Drilling, Cleveland County District Court, Case No. CJ-2008-2412-L (2009)

Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania v. Weaver, Bucks County Juvenile Court (2004)
Pennsylvania v. Wilson, Westmoreland County Court of Common Pleas, Criminal Division, Docket No. CP-65-CR-0002666-2005 (2006)
Pennsylvania v. King, Westmoreland County Court of Common Pleas, Criminal Division, Docket No. CP-65-CR-0003646-2004 (2006)
Pennsylvania v. Christopher, Somerset County Court of Common Pleas, Criminal Division, Docket No. 1097-2004 (2007)
Cheatham v. Kratsa, Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas, General Division, Docket No. GD-06-5788 (2007)
Pennsylvania v. Carrara, Centre County Court of Common Pleas, Criminal Division, Docket No. CP-14CR-1841-2007 (2007)
Pennsylvania v. Seibert, York County Court of Common Pleas, Criminal Division, Docket No. CP-67-CR-0006650-2009 (2010)

Pennsylvania Appellate
Pennsylvania v. Safka, Superior Court of Pennsylvania, Case No. 1312 WDA 2012 (2014)

South Carolina
South Carolina v. Cassels, Beaufort County, General Session Indictment No. 2002 GF 070372 (2003)

South Dakota
South Dakota v. Janklow, 3rd Circuit Court, Case No. 03-147 (2003)

Tennessee
Tennessee v. Holladay, Anderson County Criminal Court, Case No. A4CR0055 (2004)
Tennessee v. Killings, Rutherford County Criminal Court, Case No. 62681 (2010)

Tennessee Appellate
Tennessee v. Holladay, Court of Criminal Appeals, Knoxville, Case No. E2004-02858-CCA-R3-CD (2006)

Texas
Texas v. Zachary, 24th Judicial District Court, Case No. 36975 (2006)
Texas v. Talamantes, 331st Judicial District Court, Case No. 06-202270 and 06-301029 (2007)
Texas v. Kirsch, County Criminal Court at Law No. 8, Harris County, Case No. 1383625 (2007)
Texas v. Jones, 199th Judicial District Court, Case No. 199-81720-08 (2010)

Texas Appellate
Sipes v. General Motors Corporation, 946 SW 2d 143 (1997)
Kirsch v. Texas, 1st District Court of Appeals, Case No. 01-07-00446-CR (2008)

Virginia
Virginia v. O’Connell, Chesterfield Circuit Court, Case No. CR04F009991 (2004)
Johnson v. Hairston, et al, 21st Judicial District, Henry County Circuit Court, Case No. CL 05-063 (2007)
Virginia v. Reynolds, 9th Judicial District, Gloucester County Circuit Court, Case No. CR-07000106-00 (2007)
Virginia v. Nininger and Virginia v. Dupree, 161st Circuit Court, Roanoke County, Case No. CR08000558 and CR08000560 (2008)

Washington
Washington v. Swirtz, Snohomish County Superior Court, Case No. 04-1-02968-1 (2007)

Washington Appellate
Washington v. Swirtz, Court of Appeals, Division 1, Case No. 60662-0-I (2008)

Wisconsin
Wisconsin v. Furst, Outagamie County Circuit Court, Case No. 00CF667 (2001)